Posted on February 5, 2008 at 9:18 AM
Filed Under:
Baseball
First off, if you've not seen it,
Redbirds Fun has gotten up their UCB All-Star team posting. This is the last UCB project until mid-March, when we do our predictions around the majors in a week-long extravaganza. So be on the lookout for that when the time comes.
The big news in Cardinal Nation is the
signing of Juan Gonzalez. When the rumors of this first broke, there were some people that really went
overboard criticizing it. It seems to be that it's one of the classic moves of the Cardinals the last couple of years. Low risk, high reward.
I mean, it's a minor league invite. It's possible the team will spend more in gas for the bus in spring training than they will paying Juan Gone. And he easily could be this season's version of Greg Vaughn, who has nothing left in the tank and retires during spring training.
But what if it isn't? What if it's closer to 2007 Sammy Sosa? You won't see MVP-level offense from him, that's obvious. But a guy that could hit 15-20? For the league minimum? If nothing else, he could really help out the bench.
I think the most telling thing is who is recommending him. It's not a sight-unseen, "let's bring in a name" type of signing. You have numerous people, probably most importantly including Albert Pujols, who are impressed with his workouts. It's not a front office thing, it's not a player thing, it seems to have support from both levels, which gives this a better chance, in my mind, of being a success.
Besides, the Cardinals really need that right-handed bat in the outfield. The question becomes, who gets squeezed if Gonzalez is back to form?
We'll start finding out soon. Pitchers and catchers in just over a week.
Leave a comment
3 Comments
Gone couldn't play the OF in his prime, so why would anyone think he'll be adequate out there now? So the right-handed outfielder argument doesn't hold water.
Is he a better power bat off the bench than Josh Phelps? In his prime, that's a slam-dunk; now, with 3-4 years having passed since his last meaningful at-bat at the major league level, I'm not so sure.
AP is a great player, and has more experience evaluating talent than I do; but I don't see how this move helps us. Also, there is no language (according to the St Post-Dispatch) in his contract with a provision on sending him to AAA if he doesn't make the roster; so if he doesn't make the team, then what?
This move does nothing for me. If he makes the team, cool. If he doesn't, cool. As long as he's not hanging around taking ABs away from some of the younger guys.
You definitely don't want to play him and Duncan in the outfield at the same time, I'll grant you. But I doubt he'll be a terrible liability if his bat is back to some sort of resemblance of his prior level.