Before we get started, if you are looking for the Chicago YNOT, it's below. If you've not played before, go ahead and give it a shot!
Of course, just about anything is preferable to talking about yesterday's game. I think I saw on Twitter it's the first time they'd coughed up a four-run lead in the ninth at home since 1998. Even with all the bullpen problems from this year, it just doesn't happen much.
All the momentum, all the buzz, all the excitement took a major body blow yesterday afternoon. The Cards were just a couple of outs away from pulling within one game of Atlanta, with a very solid chance of tying them for the wild card today. The pressure was on the Braves, everything was going the Cardinals way. This was going to be a September long remembered.
And then the ninth happened.
The Goat tag is going to go to Jason Motte, because when it comes down to it he didn't get the job done. However, there's a lot of blame to go around in that ninth, starting with Tony La Russa. La Russa's idea that he wasn't going to let the Mets get back into it, that he was going for the closer in a four-run lead, just doesn't hold water for me. He didn't go get Motte after he'd loaded the bases, even though he'd thrown a lot of pitches and didn't look sharp. Which I guess if you are committed to him, waiting to see if he couldn't get a fly ball or a double play and pretty much get out of it.
Still, sending Motte out there was pretty irresponsible. He'd thrown an inning and a third the night before (and gave up a run), he'd thrown 2/3 of an inning on Monday (ineffectively, giving up two runs and getting yanked) and he'd thrown again on Friday, giving up an unearned run. You have to go back over a week to have a clean outing from him. You've got a four run lead and a closer that's looking gassed--use the other arms. That'd been a great time to use Fernando Salas--even though Salas has been used some lately, he'd had a day off and his last two outings were clean. Salas had troubles in this one and got the blown save, but he came into a bases-loaded, one-out situation that was spiraling quickly out of control instead of starting off an inning.
For that matter, Mitchell Boggs, the forgotten man in the bullpen, would have been a perfect choice. Have Motte or Salas warm up behind him if you don't trust him, but he's pitched once since Labor Day. Four runs shouldn't be a situation that you can't manage to stem, especially if you keep some of your bullets for later on. Remember, Boggs used to be a closer (OK, that was for like two days, but still) and has some pretty tolerable outings. He gives up a run a little more often than you'd like, but you have a four run lead. It's worth a chance there.
Of course, if Rafael Furcal could catch a ball, we might not be having this conversation. I mentioned yesterday that he's playing like he's a double agent for the Braves, being that he started his career there. Save his leadoff double, nothing from yesterday did anything to sway that opinion. The whole reason Furcal is out there, the whole reason John Mozeliak traded for him, was the fact that he could play defense. Now he's made 10 errors as a Cardinal and has a fielding percentage of .957. Now, I know FP is about the most basic and not all that accurate way of measuring defense and his range factor per 9 for St. Louis is one of his highest in his career, but still, 10 errors? Ryan Theriot made 17, but in 91 games at short. Furcal has played 47. Furcal is an upgrade, of course, but lately he's been lacking at the one thing that he's got to be good at.
You have to think that two botched plays in back to back days that lead to huge rallies for the other team will not go over well with the front office as they consider a Furcal extension. In fact, Mozeliak on the radio yesterday before the game indicated that, after the Lance Berkman signing (and more on that in a bit) they probably weren't going to do anything else until after the season. You can look at that and say that they don't want to interfere with this last week, but I think, being that they were very gung ho on an extension earlier in the month, that you can also read that as a waning of confidence in Furcal.
There were good things in yesterday's game, of course. The Hero would be Allen Craig, I think. I thought his two run home run in the first was going to be the catalyst to a runaway game. It wasn't quite that way, though the Cards did score six and have chances for more, but I don't think any blame can be put on Craig's shoulders. Yadier Molina also had a big game, getting to a new high in RBI after putting two more in the stat sheet. Albert Pujols went deep for his only hit, getting him to 98 RBI. Just two more, and with his average still at .304, there's a good chance he'll hit his milestones.
Can I tell you what I'm afraid of? Momentum is huge. You see it in all the sports, but here's the example from baseball. You've seen a team get down 9-2 early on, but they chip away, then they have a big sixth inning. A couple of runs score, they are down 9-7, with the bases loaded and one out. Everything is going their way and it looks like they are unstoppable.
Then the batter raps into a double play. Everything drains out of the team and, even though they are just down two now instead of seven, their chance is gone and they wind up losing by that score or perhaps a couple of more. Everything turned on that one at-bat.
Is that what happened yesterday? I don't know. I hope not. However, momentum is a crazy thing at times. A win in that one and the energy, the excitement, everything builds for tonight with Chris Carpenter going against the Cubs and the Braves having to deal with Stephen Strasburg. Now, even if those things go the Cards way, they are still one game out with just five more to play. It feels different, it feels harder, it feels like things have slipped through their fingers.
I also am just not sure that the Cards can lose another one. If the Cards go 6-0, the Braves can go 4-2 for the tiebreaking game. That's tough for them when they face Philly and a Nationals team that has been difficult for them in the past. If the Cards go 5-1, the Braves can go 3-3, which seems much more doable.
The Cards don't want that tiebreaker game anyway, because going into Philadelphia (if they won it) with your rotation a little out of kilter and the bullpen not rested isn't exactly the best recipe for success. A sweep of the Cubs this weekend with the Braves losing two of three and I'd feel a lot more comfortable, but I think the math just got a lot tougher with yesterday's loss.
Now, the Cards could go easily 6-0 if they can bounce back. Having Carpenter on the mound tonight will help with the momentum, assuming he can have another one of his big games. The buzz and energy will be back if they can pull it back within one. The Cubs and Astros were long ago eliminated as relevant. There's a great chance they can put together that kind of run, but remember one thing. The Cards have only won 5 in a row once this year. Yesterday would have been the second time, and we see how that worked out.
St. Louis made other news yesterday, of course, resigning Berkman to a one-year deal. A $12 million deal, which is probably less than he'd have gotten on the free agent market. I like the deal--I've enjoyed having Berkman on the team, but it doesn't lock the team up like the Jake Westbrook and Kyle Lohse deals have. If Berkman's resurgence this year was a temporary thing, the Cards can get out from under it after next season. If it wasn't, I wouldn't be surprised for another one-year deal.
That said, there were some on Twitter that expressed some discontent with this, saying that Allen Craig deserves a full-time slot. I can't argue much with that, as Craig has proven he can hit and is definitely worthy of being a starter in the big leagues. And, of course, if Albert walks this offseason, Craig would be the starter in right as Berkman would move to first, but I don't think any of us want to entertain Pujols somewhere else. Apparently, though, Mozeliak talked to Craig before the deal was announced and told him they expected to get him regular at-bats at first, left and right, with center and second up to the manager. If Tony's back next year, I think you'll see Craig on a regular basis, moving around the diamond like a souped-up Secret Weapon.
Cubs are in town tonight. If you have to bounce back from a crushing defeat, it's good to have the ace on the hill. Here's Carpenter against the Cubbies:
Dempster's had his issues as well. As you can see, Berkman and Pujols have taken him yard a lot. I noticed one of the beat writers on Twitter saying they expected a break for Furcal tonight and, given those numbers, I'd think it's a darn good possibility.
Could be a fun one this evening. It's a must-win, so let's see the Cards win it!
The Baseball Bloggers Alliance was formed in 2009 to foster
communication and collaboration between bloggers across baseball.
Member blogs are encouraged to use one another to deepen their
understanding of the game and the teams that play it. You can see the constitution of the group here.
The BBA has, as a secondary aim, the goal of producing year-end
awards in a similar fashion to the Baseball Writers of America. These
awards can be found at the official site in October with links back to the voters,
ensuring transparency and, most likely, the onset of some good baseball
arguments.
Leave a comment